Busted for Beige!

Unbeknownst to me, I have an attraction to beige/black/brown combination shoes...
My coworker Robin has teased me relentlessly about it and I think we should try to narrow these puppies down...I received some comments about two pairs in particular, that had viewers known of the second pair, they would have voted less friendly towards the first, etc. I am dueling these babies against each other now.

You know the drill, vote "Keep" in favor of keeping the left and "Toss" in favor of keeping the right.
The left are Day 11's Jackie O post. Low wedge, peep toe, these are completely comfortable.

The right are Day 12's Need for Tweed post. Tan leather, chocolate stitching, comfortable heel! I must confess I cannot decide which pair I prefer, so I'll let you!
And now for the shoes...

Vote "Keep" for the left pair and "Toss" for the right. My closet thanks you!!!
"I like everything perfect. Everything has to be neat. My sister is 5, and she's more messy than I am. I make my bed every morning, everything's perfect. My shoes are all arranged. It's sad. I'm a little like Ray, a little bit."-Dakota Fanning